Skip to main content

‘Hum Dekhenge’ controversy: Was Faiz Ahmed Faiz, Anti-Hindu?


twittergoogle-plus
‘Hum Dekhenge’ controversy: Was Faiz Ahmed Faiz, Anti-Hindu?
Faiz’s most famous poem “Hum Dekhenge” got both the writer and the singer in trouble. The year was 1985. A packed auditorium in Lahore, with more than 50,000 in attendance. It was the first death anniversary of Faiz Ahmed Faiz. A woman dressed in a black saree takes the stage and starts singing the poem.
This was followed by an immediate commotion in the crowd. The poem incited the passion of rebellion in the audience. This woman was none other than Iqbal Bano, one of the most beloved singers of Pakistan. “Hum Dekhenge”, was written by renowned Pakistani poet, Faiz Ahmed Faiz. As per reports, Iqbal Bano was later banned from singing anywhere in Pakistan. The immortal lines of ‘Hum Dekhenge’ were written in 1979 after the religiously conservative and repressive Zia rose to power through a coup in 1977. Since poetry is considered to be the best language of dissent, through this poem, the poet tried to criticise the dictatorship of former Pakistani general-turned president Zia-ul-Haq.  
Late Pakistani author, Faiz Ahmed Faiz's popular poem "Hum Dekhenge" has snowballed into a fresh controversy, this time in India, after some students of the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kanpur recited it in protest against the government's alleged atrocity on students of Jamia Millia Islamia in Delhi. This happened when Jamia Milia students were protesting against the Citizenship Amendment Act.  
The Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, has reportedly taken offence at Faiz Ahmad Faiz’s famous poem “Hum Dekhenge” recited by students against the Citizenship Amendment Act, on campus in December. Nevertheless, at Jamia Millia Islamia in New Delhi, too, a professor complained “that protesting students had made communal remarks at the event”. 
The verse that gave offence was: Ab arz-e-Khuda ke Ka’abe se, sab but uthwaae jaayenge / Hum ahl-e-safa mardood-e-haram, masnad pe bithaaye jaayenge / Sab taaj uchhale jaayenge, sab takht giraaye jaayenge/ Bas naam rahega Allah ka, hum dekhenge (From the abode of God, when the idols of falsehood will be removed/ When we, the faithful, who have been barred from sacred places, will be seated on a high pedestal/ When crowns will be tossed, when thrones will be brought down, only Allah’s name will remain) .
Top poets and writers including Javed Akhtar, Rahat Indori and Vishal Bhardwaj have described attempts to paint Faiz Ahmad Faiz’s “Hum Dekhenge”, as anti-Hindu and pro-islam, as ridiculous and baseless attempts.  
However, these writers and poets which also include those demonstrating protests against CAA across India, do not represent every Indian citizen. There are people, and certainly larger number of people who think, that their sentiments have been hurt through this poem. Given the selective media coverage, a clear picture of the whole story fails to reach the common man living in India. This can be said, because going back, one realises that whether its CAA, NPR, Abrogation of article 370 or Ayodhya issue, all these found a place in Bharatiya Janata Party’s poll manifesto.
It was on the basis of these poll promises that Indian citizens voted BJP to power and not any other party. Since BJP won 303 Lok Sabha seats in 2019 general election, a clear majority, which was also an indication that majority of Indian citizens agreed with the BJP’s policies and ideas. Army rule doesn’t exist in India, as is the case with Pakistan.
Given the fact that Faiz Ahmad Faiz’s “Hum Dekhenge” was an attempt to criticise the govt of that time, which was dominated by the Pakistani millitary. In India we have a democratically elected govt, hence reciting the same poem in Indian context which is entirely different, is all together an absurd idea and does not go by any logic.  
Secondly, Faiz did not show any activism in support of minority Hindus of Pakistan. There exist no instances where this poet wrote anything revolutionary highlighting the plight of Hindu communities living in Pakistan. It is inappropriate for a writer/poet, to raise voice on one issue and neglect the other, when both of them are related with freedom and Human rights. 
Thirdly, enough incidents have come into light which reveal that few among those who are protesting against CAA and reciting “Hum Dekhenge”, are neither aware of the Act nor do they know the meaning of this poem. These people are mostly those, who like easy things and as such it suits their convenience if they follow a herd.  
It was Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto govt, that declared Ahmadis non-Muslims via a constitutional amendment in 1974. Faiz Ahmed Faiz was an aide of Bhutto. Faiz worked in various ministries in Bhutto government, in advisory and senior roles. He did not resign to protest what Bhutto did to Ahmediyas. A revolutionary poet should have done at least that. Similarly, his activism remained totally absent when Pakistan Army was involved in the genocide in East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). Unfortunately, Faiz’s revolutionary poetic style appears limited to opposing Zia-ul-Haq only, and a trigger for that might be a selfish reason because Zia had ousted Bhutto from power. 
Lastly, “hum dekhenge” can be considered to be provocative since the poem includes metaphors where Islam prevailing over idolatry is being equated with an act of revolution. It is therefore necessary for those advocating for the recital of this poem to realise that one’s ‘Right to freedom of speech and expression’ should not compromise with the religious sentiments of another community. As responsible citizens we should be capable enough to distinguish between speech that only criticises an order and speech with malicious intent that incites people into disturbing public order.  

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

जामिया प्रोटेस्ट - पुलिस ने लाइब्रेरी में की हिंसा, हमने सड़क पर बना ली लाइब्रेरी!

“उन्होंने हमारी लाइब्रेरी में घुसकर हिंसा की, हमने सड़क पर लाइब्रेरी बना ली। आप कभी भी जाकर देखिए सड़क पर आंदोलन के बीच स्टूडेंट्स पढ़ते हुए दिख जाएंगे। वो हमें मार-पीट सकते हैं पर हमारे हौसले को नहीं तोड़ सकते। पढ़ाई और लड़ाई साथ साथ चलेगी।” - जामिया मिलिया इस्लामिया विश्वविद्यालय के गेट नंबर सात के सामने चल रहे आंदोलन के दौरान जामिया के एक छात्र ने यह बात कही। जामिया मिलिया इस्लामिया विश्वविद्यालय परिसर में बच्चों के ऊपर बर्बर पुलिस अत्याचार की घटना को एक महीने से अधिक समय हो गया है। लेकिन इस घटना में न कोई एफआईआर लिखी गई है न ही कोई कार्रवाई हुई है। विवि प्रशासन के वरिष्ठ अधिकारी ने बताया कि प्रशासन की तमाम कोशिशों के बावजूद पुलिस ने FIR नहीं लिखी है। विश्वविद्यालय   प्रशासन   की   कोशिशें   नाकाफी जामिया कोर्डिनेशन कमेटी की सफूरा ने कहा कि FIR दर्ज़ कराने के लिए जितनी कोशिशें विश्वविद्यालय प्रशासन की कोशिशें नाकाफी थीं। उन्होंने कहा कि विश्वविद्यालय के वाइस चांसलर ने 17 तारीख़ को पुलिस के खिलाफ FIR दर्ज़ कराने को लेकर स्टूडेंट्स को आश्वस्त...

Coronavirus - a disease, thousands of deaths, growing worries, frightened people

कोरोना वायरस से देश में बढ़ रहा खतरा:  कोरोनावायरस (COVID-19 ) , दुनिया के 180 से ज्यादा देशों के लोग इससे प्रभावित है, लाखों लोगों को यह अपनी चपेट में ले चुका है, हजारों लोग इस बीमारी से अपनी जान गँवा चुके है। WHO (World Health Organisation) इस वायरस को   महामारी घोषित   कर चुका है। चीन, इटली, स्पेन, ईरान, जर्मनी, अमेरिका, ऑस्ट्रेलिया, UK जैसे कई विकसित देश इस बीमारी के आगे घुटने टेक चुके है। इस वायरस से मरने वालों की संख्या हजारों में है।    हालांकि इन सभी देशों ने इस वायरस को रोकने के लिए हर संभव प्रयास किये थे और कर भी रहे है, लेकिन हालात अब बिगड़ चुके है। अगर भारत की बात की जाए तो यहां भी इस वायरस से संक्रमित लोगों का   आंकड़ा 700 के पार हो चला है और 14 से अधिक लोगों की मौत   भी हो चुकी है। हालांकि यह नंबर बाकी देशों की तुलना में काफी कम है लेकिन ख़तरा गंभीर ही है। इसके रोकथाम के लिए सरकार अपने स्तर पर प्रयास करती दिख रही है।  इन हालात में क्या सही है और क्या गलत: सबसे पहले तो हमें यह समझने की जरूरत है कि जो फैसले सरकार ले रही है वो हमारी भला...

How civil society, opposition & students responded to the CAA

Amidst growing uproar over the  Citizenship Amendment Act  across the country, the police on Saturday, arrested the Bhim army chief Chandrashekhar Azad, outside the Jama Masjid in Delhi. Though Azad was denied a permission to protest, he was spotted in a huge crowd which gathered in front of Jama Masjid after the Friday prayers. During the protest the dalit leader was seen holding the photograph of B R Ambedkar. Slogans of ‘Jai Bhim’ rang out from the steps of Jama Masjid. Recent crackdown by police officers on peaceful protesters is uncalled for in a healthy democracy. Earlier to this several protests and the subsequent arrest of the protesters took place in the National Capital region. Days have passed, however, the anger against the contentious law doesn’t seem to calm down. On Friday, eleven persons were killed in several clashes between protestors and police in parts of  Uttar Pradesh . Several other States which include Karnataka, West Bengal, Assa...